If you HAD to pick....Sideboard dilemma...

Monday, April 11, 2011

So hubby and I are at a standstill over a kitchen sideboard decision. This has been going on for a year. He will not go for anything old or vintage and wants a new piece. I'll compromise because I really want  to get this kitchen somewhat completed so we have decided we'll let my readers decide on which way to go ( I can't believe he even agreed to this but he claims his choice is the far superior one and everyone in the universe will agree with him). So here we go. This is our space that needs a new sideboard. We have a glass kitchen table (not pictured) and dark leather parson chairs.
Please ignore the mess. We put this temporary table up last October for my kid's birthday for a buffet area and well, it never went back down. Now it holds all the kids crafts and random newspapers.
Hubby Option. He likes the copper and thinks it will go with our ugly fruitwood kitchen cabinets. Cirque Three Door Sideboard available at Crate & Barrel.
My pick. I love the grainy wood and legs and I think will look good for a long time. I don't really care if it matches or not. Bathurst Credenza from Style Garage.
So which one folks? They cost around the same (Style Garage has a promotion going on). Which one would you pick for the space? Please give your opinion so that this feud will finally be over!

20 comments:

Pudel-design said... [Reply to comment]

Both of them look great, but I think your pick is better, like the legs more on the second one;)

http://pudel-design.blogspot.com/

laxsupermom said... [Reply to comment]

Love the legs on yours, and the horizontal graining is to die for, but I'm an absolute sucker for copper so your hubs' choice gets my vote. Sorry.

Anonymous said... [Reply to comment]

I'm with you! your table has more character and looks more spacious...for all those wonderful "goodies"!

Pardeep

christine {bijouandboheme} said... [Reply to comment]

I like them both but definitely prefer your choice- although it's modern, the grainy wood warms it up making it seem softer than the other.

Shannon @ What's Up Whimsy said... [Reply to comment]

I'm going with your choice on this one. I like the grain detail and the legs better than the other one.

Kala said... [Reply to comment]

I second your choice, I am a contemporary kind of gal and like the lighter color and the legs on your choice:):) Though copper is sleek and sophisticated...

Calmly Chaotic said... [Reply to comment]

I love your choice as well. It is light and airy looking, not so heavy. Good luck!!

tina - Half Of What I Say said... [Reply to comment]

I'm definitely partial to the second as it would be a lovely fit in my house. My kitchen cabinets are quarter sawn walnut aligned horizontally, much like your choice.

LINDA from OEKE said... [Reply to comment]

Sorry to your hubby - but I too like no. 2.

Wallpaper said... [Reply to comment]

I like your pick on this one, because it seems much larger and grander, and you can get storage out of it, plus I agree that the wood tones are much softer and I love when things aren't too matchy!

Good luck ;)

shrewt said... [Reply to comment]

I like your pick too. The horizontal wood grain and legs are very stylish. I find the first one a little too heavy-looking.

Aubrey {All Things Bright and Beautiful} said... [Reply to comment]

I think I actually might like the hubby's better (I know, you hate me right now)...*BUT* I think you are right that your choice will actually look better in the space and look better for longer! See, I really sided with you (c;

Shanthi said... [Reply to comment]

Both are nice. But with the little peak of the chair and the kitchen cabinet I can see, I give my vote to your better half :-)

Lisa said... [Reply to comment]

I love your husband's pick. I always gravitate toward darker, more masculine styles.

Sound Horn Please said... [Reply to comment]

The first one! The hubby gets my vote :)

Karena said... [Reply to comment]

If you are really going to put us in the middle of this :) I do love your choice the best!!

xoxo
Karena
Art by Karena

Sudha said... [Reply to comment]

love the second one!! it is timeless

Marcus Design said... [Reply to comment]

Your pick!! I love it, the grain is fantastic :)
Nancy xo

Sidu said... [Reply to comment]

sorry hubby gets my vote.. the copper tint speaks to me ;>

Yuanyuan Lin said... [Reply to comment]

7.14llllllyuan"pandora jewelry"
"oakley sunglasses"
"polo ralph lauren"
"tory burch outlet"
"cazal outlet"
"lebron shoes"
"michael kors outlet clearance"
"ray ban sunglasses"
"coach handbags outlet"
"ralph lauren outlet"
"cheap jordan shoes"
"polo shirts"
"rolex watches"
"lebron james shoes"
"coach outlet"
"ysl outlet"
"lululemon pants"
"coach outlet clearance"
"mcm backpack"
"hermes outlet store"
"true religion uk outlet"
"mont blanc pens"
"swarovski jewelry"
"swarovski crystal"
"toms outlet"
"rolex outlet"
"michael kors wallet"
"hermes birkin"
"reebok trainers"
"nfl jersey wholesale"
"nike free running"
"tiffany and co"
"michael kors factory outlet"
"reebok shoes"
"nike huarache"
7.14

Post a Comment